Book Notes: Walden by Henry David Thoreau

Walden Pond

Hard to imagine another book that is today both very-American in its reputation and creative instinct, and yet un-American in its messages and criticisms, about the best way to live, the nature of government and so on.

Understanding and finishing it was a struggle but, like a set of wind sprints, worth the effort. Among the below — all direct quotes, organized by themes — are ways of seeing the world that I’ll refer to often. To rephrase Yoshida Kenko, reading this book was communing with someone from the past whom I’ll never meet…

I learned this, at least, by my experiment: that if one advances confidently in the direction of his dreams, and endeavors to live the life which he has imagined, he will meet with a success unexpected in common hours. He will put some things behind, will pass an invisible boundary; new, universal, and more liberal laws will begin to establish themselves around and within him; or the old laws be expanded, and interpreted in his favor in a more liberal sense, and he will live with the license of a higher order of beings. In proportion as he simplifies his life, the laws of the universe will appear less complex, and solitude will not be solitude, nor poverty poverty, nor weakness weakness. If you have built castles in the air, your work need not be lost; that is where they should be. Now put the foundations under them. – Henry David Thoreau, Walden, free on Kindle

His thoughts on a free, simple and timeless life

Public opinion is a weak tyrant compared with our own private opinion. What a man thinks of himself, that it is which determines, or rather indicates, his fate.

We know but few men, a great many coats and breeches. Dress a scarecrow in your last shift, you standing shiftless by, who would not soonest salute the scarecrow?

Simplify, simplify. Instead of three meals a day, if it be necessary eat but one; instead of a hundred dishes, five; and reduce other things in proportion.

…for I lived like the Puri Indians, of whom it is said that “for yesterday, today, and tomorrow they have only one word, and they express the variety of meaning by pointing backward for yesterday forward for tomorrow, and overhead for the passing day.”

Many a forenoon have I stolen away, preferring to spend thus the most valued part of the day; for I was rich, if not in money, in sunny hours and summer days, and spent them lavishly; nor do I regret that I did not waste more of them in the workshop or the teacher’s desk.

Rise free from care before the dawn, and seek adventures. Let the noon find thee by other lakes, and the night overtake thee everywhere at home.

I would fain keep sober always; and there are infinite degrees of drunkenness. I believe that water is the only drink for a wise man; wine is not so noble a liquor; and think of dashing the hopes of a morning with a cup of warm coffee, or of an evening with a dish of tea!

All sensuality is one, though it takes many forms; all purity is one. It is the same whether a man eat, or drink, or cohabit, or sleep sensually. They are but one appetite, and we only need to see a person do any one of these things to know how great a sensualist he is. The impure can neither stand nor sit with purity.

His thoughts on philosophy and human nature

To be a philosopher is not merely to have subtle thoughts, nor even to found a school, but so to love wisdom as to live according to its dictates, a life of simplicity, independence, magnanimity, and trust. It is to solve some of the problems of life, not only theoretically, but practically

Children, who play life, discern its true law and relations more clearly than men

For what are the classics but the noblest recorded thoughts of man?

I found in myself, and still find, an instinct toward a higher, or, as it is named, spiritual life, as do most men, and another toward a primitive rank and savage one, and I reverence them both.

Those things for which the most money is demanded are never the things which the student most wants. Tuition, for instance, is an important item in the term bill, while for the far more valuable education which he gets by associating with the most cultivated of his contemporaries no charge is made.

Our whole life is startlingly moral. There is never an instant’s truce between virtue and vice. Goodness is the only investment that never fails.

It is said that Mirabeau took to highway robbery “to ascertain what degree of resolution was necessary in order to place one’s self in formal opposition to the most sacred laws of society.”

His thoughts on nature, the outdoors, the value of physical labor

My purpose in going to Walden Pond was not to live cheaply nor to live dearly there, but to transact some private business with the fewest obstacles; to be hindered from accomplishing which for want of a little common sense, a little enterprise and business talent, appeared not so sad as foolish.

I got up early and bathed in the pond; that was a religious exercise, and one of the best things which I did. They say that characters were engraven on the bathing tub of King Tchingthang to this effect: “Renew thyself completely each day; do it again, and again, and forever again.” I can understand that. Morning brings back the heroic ages.

I have never felt lonesome, or in the least oppressed by a sense of solitude, but once, and that was a few weeks after I came to the woods, when, for an hour, I doubted if the near neighborhood of man was not essential to a serene and healthy life.

But labor of the hands, even when pursued to the verge of drudgery, is perhaps never the worst form of idleness.

Walden book cover

His thoughts on our grasping, materialist culture

Our inventions are wont to be pretty toys, which distract our attention from serious things. They are but improved means to an unimproved end, an end which it was already but too easy to arrive at

Nations are possessed with an insane ambition to perpetuate the memory of themselves by the amount of hammered stone they leave.

We are eager to tunnel under the Atlantic and bring the Old World some weeks nearer to the New; but perchance the first news that will leak through into the broad, flapping American ear will be that the Princess Adelaide has the whooping cough.

Absolutely speaking, the more money, the less virtue; for money comes between a man and his objects, and obtains them for him; and it was certainly no great virtue to obtain it. It puts to rest many questions which he would otherwise be taxed to answer; while the only new question which it puts is the hard but superfluous one, how to spend it.

The best thing a man can do for his culture when he is rich is to endeavor to carry out those schemes which he entertained when he was poor.

His thoughts on the role of government, the State

The government itself, which is only the mode which the people have chosen to execute their will, is equally liable to be abused and perverted before the people can act through it.

There are thousands who are in opinion opposed to slavery and to the war, who yet in effect do nothing to put an end to them; who, esteeming themselves children of Washington and Franklin, sit down with their hands in their pockets, and say that they know not what to do, and do nothing;

Thus the State never intentionally confronts a man’s sense, intellectual or moral, but only his body, his senses. It is not armed with superior wit or honesty, but with superior physical strength.

The progress from an absolute to a limited monarchy, from a limited monarchy to a democracy, is a progress toward a true respect for the individual.

Bertrand Russell on why science — and today, technology — is the happiest profession

Of the highly-educated professions, the happiest today are the men of science. Many of them get such pleasure from their work that they can be happy even in marriage. Artists and writers consider it normal to be unhappily married, but scientists can often achieve so-called domestic bliss. This is because their highest intellects are so absorbed by their work, that they’re not allowed to invade other parts of their life where they would be harmful. They’re happy with their work because science today is progressive and powerful, and its importance is never questioned by themselves or the broader population.

This was written before World War II, yet swap “men of science” with “men of technology” and it’d ring true today. I think a career in science has lost value in many areas and for many reasons. A reduction in career prestige. Less everyday appreciation among the public, and more irrational outrage (eg, GMOs). The increasingly specialized nature of PhD programs. The stagnant academic job market. Challenges in higher ed posed by technology and software. And so on.

But technology today is progressive and powerful. Its importance is not questioned, really, by technologists or the broader population. Their jobs consume their mental energy. Hard to think of another highly-educated profession which is “happier”.

On the science vs technology divide, Kevin Kelly has a great piece.

*I have no opinion on domestic bliss…remember, in Russell’s time, female labor participation was below 25%. Mad Men was progressive by comparison

**I’m rewriting Russell’s The Conquest of Happiness, here’s a snippet

Slavoj Zizek is a crazy dude (who might be right)

Slavoj Zizek is crazy, bombastic and possibly a genius.

Wikipedia has this to say:

He has been labelled by some the “Elvis of cultural theory” and Foreign Policy listed him on its 2012 list of Top 100 Global Thinkers, calling him “a celebrity philosopher.”

Slavoj Zizek fans are telling you: I think differently, often radically. I am a little nihilist. This is my intuition, and I’m still figuring out my own reaction.

The below notes are from his Authors@Google talk, one of his more thorough talks on YouTube.

  • ideology — the network of ethical, political, social prejudices — is everywhere, it structures our lives
  • Donald Rumsfeld’s famous quote before the Gulf War — “there are known knowns, known unknowns, etc…”
    • but what about unknown knowns? knowledge so embedded in our lives that we don’t know that we know them
    • another example of unknown known: structure of toilets; there are 3 types (French toilets have hole in the back, German hole in front, UK doesn’t matter because it’s circular and big bowl of water)
      • this positioning is not purely utilitarian
      • analogous to European trinity, which is a way of describing all European society — Germans (conservative, thinkers), France (evolutionary, into politics), UK (liberal-centrist, utilitarian, into economics)
      • when you really dig into why toilets are constructed the way they are, that’s the only way to account for it (Germans are metaphysical, reflective, French want it to disappear, UK is a blend)
      • maybe even more than eating, shitting is reflection of a civilization
  • how do we deal with ideology today?
    • Niels Bohr, in response to why he followed a particular superstition, said, “I don’t believe in it, but I was told it works even if I don’t believe in it”
    • that’s how ideology works today
    • we practice beliefs without believing in them
    • in the past we publicly believed things and privately didn’t; now we publicly don’t believe things and privately do
    • there is a vaguely Dalai Lama-esque spiritualism
    • we believe much more than we admit to believing
  • think about canned laughter on TV — the purpose is not necessarily Pavlovian (to trigger your laughing), but literally that it laughs for you, it does the work for you; why does it work?
    • like Tibetan prayer wheel, it prays for you, it does the work
  • Israel is most atheist country in world, but its claim to land relies on God giving them the West Bank; ironically 60-70% of Israeli Jews don’t believe in God
  • most important is that we believe others believe; we need that more than our own belief
  • Gore Vidal — well-known bisexual
    • when they asked him, “was your first sexual experience with a man or a woman?”, he replied, “I was too polite to ask”
  • it’s impossible to fully understand each other, because we don’t even understand ourselves
  • we’re missing a code of discretion
  • religion is often employed after-the-fact to justify certain actions
  • example: Japanese Zen Buddhist community, which ostensibly is about peace and non-confrontation, how did they think about the invasion of China, the atrocities Japan committed in 1930s, 40s?
    • with exception of a few dissidents, not only did the Zen Buddhist community fully support the war but provided justification for it!
    • Suzuki, a Zen Buddhist who became well-known in the US in 1960s and 70s, was writing different texts in 1930s and 40s, arguing that Japanese invasion of China was work of love, to heal them; even gave advice on how a soldier can train himself psychologically to kill: the Buddhist belief in overcoming your “false self”, stabbing an enemy becomes depersonalized, you’re a 3rd party observer; military discipline is a great way to achieve Enlightenment
    • Suzuki’s meditations are authentic, and he’s not saying it’s purely militaristic, it’s just that the stories and narrative we construct about and for ourselves are always ideological
  • another example: hardcore porn
    • a porn film must have some narrative, yet it’s incredible how self-mocking they are
    • they do this on-purpose; “you can see it all, but the price you pay is to remove emotional involvement” (i.e. you can’t have a dramatic and touching film with hardcore porn)
    • gonzo sex — embedded journalism; don’t even pretend it’s a story; cameraman gives directions, woman talks to camera like it’s a director, this is high point of censorship — afraid to even have a minimum of narrative
  • in ideology, there’s always tension between what’s explicit and what’s understood
    • to penetrate social circle — whether a company, a nation, a social group — you must know the rules, but the rules are always mysterious
    • for example, in corrupt countries there are prohibitions which are meant to be violated (e.g., it’s illegal but accepted to bribe a cop or bureaucrat)
    • for example, in Japan, work contracts have 40 days of holiday but you’re not supposed to take more than 20
      • this is how links between people are created, like a shared secret
  • “not only that something is prohibited…but prohibition itself is prohibited from being stated publicly”
    • Stalinism — not only was criticizing Stalin prohibited, but even worse was announcing this publicly; so if you came to Stalin’s defense and said, ‘you cannot criticize Stalin’, that was just as bad as criticizing him!
  • evolution of advertising
    • at first advertising was utilitarian — you should buy a truck to get work done in the field
    • then it was symbolic — status symbol, Land Rover = I have money
    • today, it’s neither utilitarian nor symbolic, it’s about self-actualization, self-fulfillment, buy a Land Rover and you will be your best self, achieve your dreams
    • for example, organic food — why do we buy a rotten, 2x pricier organic apple; it’s not because we REALLY believe it’s better for our health, it’s to make us feel good (“I’m more authentic, I’m helping the world”)
  • beneath official message, always subtext
    • ideology always offers you some bribery
    • in Nazi Germany it was sacrifice for your country, do your duty; hidden message: kill some Jews, have some fun, be powerful
    • in 1900s American South, it was Christian values, community, family; hidden message: rape some women, lynch black people, have some fun
    • how about donate $20, feed a child in Africa? hidden message: don’t worry about poverty and global inequality, spend $20 and payoff your conscience
  • how to understand Sarah Palin, hidden message was: giving voice to rage of ordinary people, but things will stay same in background
    • previously female politicians were phallic, imitated men — Indira Gandhi, Margaret Thatcher (me: even Hillary to a degree)
    • Sarah Palin is more feminine yet still strong; mother, sex object AND leader, this “sarcastic assertiveness”
    • in Obama, skinny, big ears, something of the slightly weak/emaciated guy in him, Sarah Palin subtly alludes to it
  • in education today, we need more philosophy, even to solve basic problems like bioethics, abortion
  • most modern liberalism is “global capitalism with a human face”
  • maybe liberal democratic capitalism isn’t the ultimate horizon
  • Marxists always believed train of history was on their side
  • Intellectual Property is closer to Communism than Capitalism — hard to contain within limits of private property
    • look at Bill Gates, went from garage to richest man in world in 30 years, hard to say his markets work properly, that they accurately reflect his contributions
  • loves the details
    • look at totalitarian speeches e.g. Hitler; when audience applauses, Hitler accepts
    • look at communist speeches, e.g., Stalin; when audience applauses, Stalin joins the applause
  • God is the original proxy; I don’t know, but He knows for me
  • what is evil? something that brutally interrupts the status quo; it’s a cut
    • Jesus Christ is evil embodied for traditional pagan religions
    • one way to look at evil: we are doing something terribly great, something crazy, just need to do it more slowly, it’s the negative dimension/realization that what you’re doing is a huge change
    • in order to say “don’t be evil”, you must already dwell in the space of evil

Bertrand Russell’s 4 rules for avoiding persecution mania

For Bertrand Russell — mathematician, writer, philosopher — persecution mania is two things: a belief that everyone is out to GET you, or a belief that everything that happens is ABOUT you. At a cafe, the woman on the phone who glances your way is gossiping about your outfit; a truck that cuts you off in traffic doesn’t like your driving style; and on it goes…

He believes persecution mania is a cause of insanity and a barrier to happiness, and offers four rules for prevention and relief (hah, I sound like a pharmaceutical commercial):

Number 1: your motives are not as altruistic as you think

Number 2: don’t overestimate your own merits

Number 3: don’t expect others to be as interested in you as you are in yourself

Number 4: don’t assume people care enough about you to want to harm you

Wise words from a book with many more: The Conquest of Happiness. Btw, I’m rewriting it — with the occasional adjustment — in a more casual, simple voice…I’ll share when it’s done!

A must-read for Overachievers and their parents: David Brooks on parenting

Despite the lack of an overt tiger mom and family, I somehow adopted the Overachiever’s mindset at a young age. It took two decades and untold mistakes before I was able to step back and try to understand what happened with any honesty or empathy. And in this Katie Couric interview, David Brooks gave an incredible response to a question about overachievers and parents:

A lot of parents especially in our demographic love their children passionately, also desperately want their children to do really well in life, get into college, get great careers, and so these two forces collide to mean intense attention, intense effort, intense care and love for the child, but also intense anxiety about them not doing well, not getting into the right college, not getting the right job and intense love and relief when they do something well. So the kids are bombarded in a world in which when they do something well they get super bursts of love and when they don’t do something well there’s a little withdrawal and they begin to feel conditional love…I’ll love you as long as you’re on my balance beam but if you get off my balance beam you’re in trouble and we’ll cut you off, and I see this in my students, that the will for unconditional love terrifies them, it leads them to lack of internal criteria to make up their own decisions, it makes them in the most concrete sense have two majors, one for mom & dad and one for me, and they live under this inability to really lead their own lives, because the final act of parenting is letting go and I see some of the parents not come to convocation because they don’t like the job choice, and I’ve seen some very strange things in our culture, in our high-achieving high-pressure culture

This! Minute 54. Try to watch the whole thing. If you’re busy and pressed for time, you can listen to it at 1.25 or 1.5x to speed things up :)