Cognitive Investments — a good geopolitics newsletter: “Russia has its fingerprints over the last three major global geopolitical transitions”

I’m enjoying their weekly issues. You can sub here: https://www.cognitive.investments/get-to-know-us

A few highlights from recent reports, including a very thoughtful and informed assessment of crypto post-FTX:

The late 1980s was “Peak Japan” – the West was obsessed with the notion that Japan was going to overtake the U.S. as the most powerful economy in the world. Instead, Japan entered a period of lost decades, while the U.S. presided over an era of globalization, expanding free trade, technological innovation, and (relatively) unrestrained American military power. These were not the only geopolitical conventions that turned out to be wrong. Germany went from Sick Man of the Euro (we can thank The Economist for that prediction) to center of a European industrial renaissance. China emerged out of Tiananmen as the newest and largest “Asian tiger.”

It was not until Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022 that it became clear that the world had changed irrevocably – or at minimum, that global sentiment had changed irrevocably. (Aside: It is ironic that Russia has its fingerprints over the last three major global geopolitical transitions. The Russian Revolution brought us the rise of Communism and the Cold War. The collapse of the Soviet Union brought us U.S. hegemony. Might Russia’s failed invasion of Ukraine now open the door to the multipolar multiverse?)

Fiat money allows governments and central banks to be more flexible and strategic – they can design policies around interest rates and money supply without being dependent on what mining companies can extract from the ground. The downside of this is that money, whose value for so long had been based on an objective factor (the value of a precious metal), was now officially politicized.

In that sense, FTX may well be the beginning of the long-awaited clash between cryptocurrencies and governments – not because FTX is in any way representative of cryptocurrencies, but because it gives governments the excuse they need to crack down on them. It is unclear how many people lost money, or even their life savings, in the FTX debacle (an issue to societal stability in its own right), but you can be sure governments will use the FTX example as they aim to regulate cryptocurrencies into oblivion – or at least into becoming similar to other tradeable securities rather than as a fundamental threat to the future of money.

Max Weber once wrote that the state is defined in part by its claim to the monopoly on the legitimate use of physical force. I think we can add that the state claims a monopoly on the legitimate use of currencies within its borders. When the state decides to use the former to ensure the latter, we will see just how powerful cryptocurrency really is – and based on recent developments, it is a clash soon in the making.

Podcast notes – Peter Zeihan on global order and geopolitics (talk at Fort Benning)

After WW2, America used its Navy to keep global trade and shipping lanes open
Bribed our alliance to fight the Cold War – but Cold War ended 30 years ago

Americans are now done with this arrangement

Population structure was mostly a pyramid in past – more kids, less parents, fewer grandparents
On farms, kids are free labor
In town, kids are expensive pieces of furniture

China today – fastest aging society in human history – result of One Child Policy
By 2100, will have <50% of today’s population

CHINA

China imports 80% of oil needs – world’s most exposed trade route since most of it comes from Persian Gulf
China utterly dependent on US-maintained global order for these shipping guarantees

Xi has consolidated power even more than Mao
“No one wants to tell him bad news”
China vaccines don’t work against Covid – can’t move away from zero-Covid policy bc healthcare impacts would be crushing

World’s oil and gas investment is only half of what it was 10 years ago
Takes 3-8 years to develop at its fastest
Soonest energy inflation fixes itself is 2025
US blessed with lots of domestic shale – largely fixed our natural gas problems

RUSSIA
Lots of land that isn’t habitable yet can’t be easily defended
Lost control of many access points / invasion points that were controlled under the USSR
Only way Russia can protect its borders is to expand
Time’s not on Russia’s side – like China, a severe demographics problem (not enough children and young people)
Russia only has 2M troops – they’re irreplaceable, no more reserves

AFRICA
Over 5 decades, agricultural output increased by 5x
But heavily reliant on global inputs of eg, potash and other chemicals

Expects many wars of collapse as America withdraws from maintaining global order

MEXICO
One of healthiest demographies in the world
Mexico in 2060 will look approximately like US today
Exports 77% of all goods to the US – critical bilateral relationship
El Chapo ran a Korean-style conglomerate – many regional commanders that he loosely controls
He saw it as business, not warfare – once he was removed, violence increased (Sinaloa), multiple leaders
Sinaloa is largest crime group in the US today, and risk of it getting worse
Geographically similar to Afghanistan – rugged terrain, unsecurable border – may need similar tools to manage it

AMERICAN POLITICS
2×2 – economic conservative v liberal, social conservative v liberal
Military doesn’t participate in the domestic political conversation
“Greatest period of change we’ll experience in our lives”

AUDIENCE Q&A

After the Civil War, the US was split, focused domestically on re-integration, didn’t have time for diplomacy / foreign affairs
Dollar diplomacy arose – individual business interests went around the world and did what they wanted
Resulted in hemispheric chaos, led to China’s fall to Communism

Economics is an outgrowth of demography and geography (probably his core thesis)

Han (Chinese) have been around for 3K years, but only been united for 10% of it
Didn’t worry about Taiwan war until recently – but if everything else is collapsing, something to be said about choosing time/place for fight and controlling the narrative (from Xi’s perspective) – considers it 1/3 chance

If China falls:
-N China plain would be its own political entity
-City states from Shanghai to HK will integrate into extra national system / external alliances

China – sex imbalance of 5-20%
95m more men <40yo than women – driving population collapse

Bullish on Turkey – still a developing country, but all energy within arm’s reach, good agricultural inputs, good European cooperation, control / easy access to key bodies of water

Russia-Chinese alliance
Not capable of functional cooperation once you remove US’s overarching reach
Only settled border disputes ~10 years ago
Can’t sustain conflict given demography problems

The Absent Superpower by Peter Zeihan (31 highlights)

For context, I highlighted so much of the book that Kindle stopped storing my highlights, so I could only share a subset below.

The book – and his other writings, he’s quite prolific – is well worth reading if you’re into geopolitics and global trade. At the very least it’ll challenge some of your assumptions and viewpoints.

A small selection of highlights below:

  • Americans are panic-prone. Every country has a series of early experiences that shape the national mindset. For the Americans it was century-long pioneer era: for the cost of a used car in today’s dollars, Americans could Conestoga the family out to the Midwest, break ground, and within six months be exporting grain for hard currency. It was the greatest cultural and economic expansion in human history, and it taught Americans that things will get better every single year.
  • Kids […] don’t factor economically in the modern age. They used to serve as free labor on farms, but once most populations relocated into urban environments children essentially transformed into luxury goods. Think of them as more expensive Shih Tzus.
  • As the American economy evolves into a dynamic, service-oriented system, as careers give way to jobs, jobs give way to part-time work, and as part-time work gives way to hobbies that happen to generate income, the Yers are actually fairly well-prepared socially, politically, and psychologically for the new era.
  • GenX is roughly one-fifth smaller than the Boomers —considering that GenX is younger, they should be one-quarter bigger —an imbalance so extreme that GenX will not outnumber the Boomers until most of the Xers are in their sixties.
  • Like most Americans I wasn’t really sure why the Americans had walked away from the Cold War without so much as the memory of a limp while Russia was a dismembered mess. Even today Americans flinch more visibly when they think of Vietnam than they do when they think of Russia, a country that still possesses the nuclear wherewithal to end American existence.
  • the vast swathes of internal Chinese territories are physically isolated and thus painfully poor. Adding political complications to the mix, most of China’s minority groups live in the interior and most of them are not exactly thrilled to be living in the People’s Republic. The interior is home to the remaining 600 million Chinese.
  • China has a local fuel—brown coal—and has it in abundance. Consequently, in most of the past 20 years, China has added more coal-burning capacity than most of the rest of the world combined despite lip service to international climate goals and rising domestic dissatisfaction with pollution levels.
  • NAFTA may have its faults, but its economic success in Mexico has made net Mexican migration to the U.S. negative for a decade because it gives Mexicans jobs. Smash the agreements that employ Mexicans, and two results among many will be vast increases in drug flows and illegal migration as Mexicans find it harder to find a 9-to-5.
  • In about a decade, instead of living in a world where the Americans are the most powerful force for global stability, they are likely to be the most powerful force for global instability.
  • Canada knows the United States intimately, while the United States barely registers what’s going on north of its border. (The only country that even comes close to studying the United States as intently is Israel)
  • Canada’s riven geography means every Canadian province trades more with the United States than with the rest of Canada
  • Chinese People universally despise North Korea, and would drop NK in a moment if Beijing would simply give it more than a second thought.   However, the fear China uses again and again is simple;  Let North Korea fall and refugees will flood across.  Ok. Fair enough.  However, the unspoken fear is that American combat divisions will simply race up to the border and dig in
  • With their rich cultural history, the Iranians consider themselves not only the natural leaders of the region, but also the peak of the human experience. In contrast, the Saudis are a Bedouin family that just happened to cut a deal with the British at the right time and have yet to celebrate their centenary celebration. Yet they command the world’s largest oil industry, wield power that is global in scope, and are the custodians of the Holy Cities.
  • Desert life is hard, and maintaining a social structure in the desert is harder still. One of the many ways in which the Saud clan coped was the adoption of an ultra-strict version of Islam, which glorified combat and tightly regulated personal freedoms. Locals call it Salafist Islam while many outsiders know it as Wahhabism, referring to the movement’s founder, one Sheikh Ibn Abdul Wahhab.
  • Unsurprisingly, Japan now suffers under the economic weight of supporting the world’s oldest population: Japanese labor costs—the highest in Asia and among the highest in the world—nudge up a bit higher every year and the country now purchases more diapers for adults than for children. Combined, these intermingled crises have manifested as seven recessions in under 25 years.
  • The Indian geography is a complex one, riddled with river valleys, deserts, plains, mountains, hills, swamp, and a mix of coastline styles. But one feature always stands out: the Ganges Basin. Set in the oddity of a temperate zone that knows no true winter, the plain’s outstanding fertility and multiple potential growing seasons generates the largest volume of calories per acre per year of anywhere in the world. However, the Ganges itself is not navigable. The result is fantastically high rates of population growth, but fantastically low capital generation per capita. Massive populations, but crushing poverty.
  • The United States is a maritime nation. Its most strategically relevant military arm is its Navy. The core of American strategic doctrine has always been about controlling the oceans and using that control to shape global events to its liking.
  • local labor forces are very attractive because they are higher skilled than their price point would suggest—particularly in Vietnam, which boasts that magic mix of modern urban centers like Ho Chi Minh City and rural zones combined with a far-above-global-average educational standards.
  • …the American retrenchment is but one of three massive shifts in the global the order. The second is the rapid greying of the entire global population. Fewer people of working age translates directly into anemic, decaying economies — enervating global trade just as the Americans stop guaranteeing it. Third and finally, the American shale revolution has changed the mechanics — if not yet the mood — of how the Americans interact with the energy sector.
  • The end of American dependence upon extra-continental energy sources does more than sever the largest of the remaining ties that bind America’s fate to the wider world, it sets into motion a veritable cavalcade of trends: the re-industrialization of the United States, the accelerated breakdown of the global order, and a series of wide-ranging military conflicts that will shape the next two decades.
  • Without petroleum there would not be a meaningful agricultural industry — and in that I mean everything from the growing of crops to the harvesting of crops to the transport of foodstuffs from farm to table.
  • In 1920 Congress passed the Jones Act, which barred any ship from plying the American waterways that was not American-built, American-owned, American-captained, and American-crewed.
  • The American system, with the Greater Midwest and Mississippi network at its core, is not only the richest piece of territory in the world, it also is the single-most secure.
  • You can lay most of the financial bubbles (and busts) of the past two decades at the Boomers’ feet — everything from dot-com to Enron to subprime to Brazil, Russia, India, and China — all were only possible because the Boomers were ignoring risk in the quest for that extra 1% of yield.
  • The Japanese economic breakdown of 1990 wasn’t demographic in origin, but Japan has since aged past the point that it will again be a consumption-led economy. Ever.
  • As soon as 2022, Germany, Belgium, Greece, Austria, and Italy will not be past just the point of not just demographic recovery — they and more have already crossed that threshold — but financial and economic recovery as well.
  • Japan, Korea, and Taiwan has never covered more than a tiny percentage (typically less than 1%) of their energy needs.
  • Since the 1990s television power demand is down by 35% despite massive increases in quality and size. Dishwashers use 40% less electricity, air conditioners 50% less, refrigerators 60%.
  • …it isn’t just the United States that is dipping into nativism. Japan is amending its constitution to make it easier to bomb people. China is crowning a new Mao. Britain voted itself out of the European Union. The Turkish president’s leadership makes Donald Trump seem shy by comparison, Poland’s government exudes the worst characteristics of Pope Innocent III and Kanye.
  • Russian security only comes from conquering everyone nearby in order to establish buffers around the Russian core.
  • the Russians often have to find ways to motivate their conquered populations — or more to the point, to intimidate their subjects into accepting the role the Russians demand of them. The Russians do this with a deep, intrusive, and cruel intelligence service. Under Lenin it was the Cheka, under Stalin the NVBD, and Brezhnev the KGB, after the Cold War the FSB, and now it’s the FSB backed up with the social-monitoring techniques Edward Snowden brought with him from the American NSA.